TAKE ACTION: Tell President Obama, USDA to Stop Undermining Organics

saveorganicpetitionDespite the fact that organic is more popular than ever and companies such as Walmart and Target are significantly boosting their offerings, one would think that support for organic in Washington, D.C. would be growing as well.

Sadly, that is not the case.

Not only is support for organic not growing, the Obama administration and his USDA are doing everything they can to weaken organic standards and dismantle the authority of the National Organic Standards Board (NOSB), an independent, 15-member advisory board which helps to oversee the industry and make important recommendations.


One of the most important policies that we have in organic is something called The Sunset Rule.  What this means is the following.

A company can petition the NOSB to allow for the use of synthetic and non-organic materials in organic production. These materials receive temporary approval (5 years) until organic alternatives are developed — hence, the term “sunset”.

After the five years have passed, the materials are removed from approval, unless a 2/3rds vote from the NOSB allows them to remain in organic for another five years.

However, the USDA recently changed this rule so that at the end of the 5-year period, these materials will remain, unless a 2/3rds vote from the NOSB decides to remove them.

The burden of proof has completely shifted from “prove why they should stay” to “prove why they shouldn’t stay”.

And with the NOSB stacked with USDA insiders, getting these synthetic and non-organic materials removed will be incredibly difficult.

Allowing more and more synthetics approved for organic production will undermine the integrity of our industry and diminish the value of the organic seal.

In response to this Sunset Rule change, Senator Patrick Leahy of Vermont and Representative Peter DeFazio of Oregon wrote a letter to the USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack expressing their strong objection.

Alexis-Baden Mayer, Political Director of the Organic Consumers Association, was willing to get arrested at the recent NOSB meeting in San Antonio, Texas because of her outrage over this change. That is the magnitude of how important this rule is.


In addition to the Sunset Rule change, the USDA has made harmful changes as to how the NOSB operates.

It removed the ability of the NOSB to set its own work plan and agenda, effectively allowing the USDA to conduct its own meetings. The USDA also claims to have the power to co-chair NOSB meetings.

The most worrisome of them all is that the USDA changed the charter of the NOSB, which raises the possibility that the NOSB could be completely eliminated and all organic policies would be entirely in the hands of the USDA.

This is in direct violation of the Organic Food Production Act of 1990, which mandated that the NOSB exist and have an active role.


Cornucopia Institute, Center for Food Safety, Organic Consumers Association, Food & Water Watch and others have filed a petition with the USDA to reverse these changes.

This is a first step in the legal process and additional actions (lawsuits) may very well be pursued.

These watchdog organizations have done their part, and now it is time to do ours.

Please click HERE to sign the electronic petition and tell the White House not to let the
USDA undermine the governance and integrity of organic food.

We have only until August 14th to get to 100,000 signatures, so please share this post with your network as soon as possible.

Thank you so much for supporting organic food.


Want to stay up-to-date on the most important news and products in the organic food world?

If so, make sure you Like my Facebook page, follow me on Instagram and join my email list.

To join my newsletter list, please enter your email below and I’ll send you my Top 5 Inexpensive Ways to Shop Organic.

Signature: Have a great day!


  • Kimberly says:

    The link above does not go to the petition, just to the we the people website.

  • James Brackett says:

    I am curious as to where the outrage has been while the NOP chose to ignore the recommendations of their own NOSB and allow by ommision hydroponically grown crops to be certified organic. Many in the organic community have joined to at least try to hold the NOP to task using http://www.keepthesoilinorganic.org . We invited Max to join us and sign our petition and help get the word out. Did he sign? Did he get the word out?

    So, the dam has broken, just as I suspected it would as soon as the Feds got involved.
    Likewise, I am not surprised by the continued undermining and dilution of the word organic so many have come to cherish. What I must say DOES surprise me is that anyone, especially Max, who is “connected” to the organic world, would be shocked by any of this in the wake of the organic community all but lying down in apathy when it comes to the hydroponic “question” which shouldn’t even be a question.

    I am not pointing fingers at Max or individual. I am pointing at all of us. We, as a group of good, concerned citizens and farmers have become complacent in our calling to defend everything organic against those who would profit from an ambiguous definition of the word. Soil, albeit arguably the basis of organic farming, has been dismissed as optional in today’s organic marketplace under the watch of the NOP.

    You are concerned about the NOP losing power? It had little to begin with and that which it did have it did not wield in the interest of securing the integrity of Organic. So, what are you really going to do about it if you can’t even sign a petition supporting the notion that soil is crucial to organic farming?

    What are you going to do?

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *